It's impossible to know for sure what Carlson's motivations were, but one thing is certain: his actions had a profound effect on Candy. George decides to be the one to kill Lennie because he didnt want Lennie to suffer at the hands of Curley. His only company is his faithful dog companion who later in the story is killed by Carlson. For example, he was only close to his dog before he met George and Lennie and he was so eager to meet them and make friends. Lennie does not immediately fight back, instead crying and calling to George for help. Why isnt Curleys wifes name ever revealed? In order to kill Lennie, George would need a gun. The wh*re house ( Suzy's place ) It was basically a club of women for the entertainment for men. On page 44, the men are discussing Candys dog in the bunkhouse. $18.74/subscription + tax, Save 25% May 1, 2023, SNPLUSROCKS20 In an attempt to make her feel better, he told her that the dog "didn't feel a thing" and that it "didn't suffer." What happens as a result of Lennie's taking care of himself? His hand is cut off, so he can't lift stuff. Report your findings. Educators go through a rigorous application process, and every answer they submit is reviewed by our in-house editorial team. Related Read: How to stop dog from biting other dogs' necks? He thinks that Slim is with his wife. He seemed to shake himself free for speech. What is Carlsons problem with Candys dog? You seen what they done to my dog tonight? The dog is too old to be of any use and stinks up the room. 20% The guys leaves him back at the ranch while they go to drink and sleep with women. Why do George and Lennie travel together? I never been mad, an' I ain't now. Simple repairs. Why did he stop? He wrote a letter to the editor, praising the publication What is Old Susy's place? Latest answer posted December 07, 2020 at 5:10:16 PM. "That stink hangs around even after hes gone." Because Candy knows his dog is not good to shoot and he wouldn't want to be responsible for killing him. TO CANCEL YOUR SUBSCRIPTION AND AVOID BEING CHARGED, YOU MUST CANCEL BEFORE THE END OF THE FREE TRIAL PERIOD. 2023 eNotes.com, Inc. All Rights Reserved, Essential Quotes by Character: Lennie Small. Explain the parallelism between the relationship We can not guarantee its completeness or reliability so please use caution. Related Read: Why does my dog bite my other dogs neck? Ultimately, Candy agrees to Carlson's request, and the dog is shot. We go in to old Susy's place. Why did Candy agree to let Carlson shoot his old and sick dog? Why does Curley wear a Vaseline-filled glove on one hand? Related Read: Why does my dog cry when he sees other dogs? Why does Carlson insist on shooting Candy's dog? Both George and Lennie already have conflict with Curley. First of all, he says that the dog . The weapon George uses to kill Lennie had to be a pistol because George had to keep it concealed. Latest answer posted November 30, 2020 at 4:09:18 PM. "God awmighty, that dog stinks. Later, in chapter three, Carlson gives two more reasons why the dog should be put down. Curley's wife has just come into the bunkhouse "looking" for Curley. The main reason why Carlson's killing of Candy's dog was justified is because the old dog was well past its years and of no use to anyone. Lennie killed it by snapping its neck because he thought the puppy was going to bite him. The dog and its weakness is a symbolism Steinbeck used to compare to Candy and his missing hand. The dog is unable to do anything for itself and Candy is struggling to care for it, meaning that Carlson may have thought that it would be better for everyone if the animal was put down. Project. And physically Lennie survives with George, Because Lennie is bigger than him and he picks fights with bigger people. What is Carlsons solution to the problem presented by the dog? Candy says that he should have shot the dog, and that "you shoot your own dog.". Additionally, Carlson believes that the dog is a threat because it might bite him or someone else. That dog ain't no good to himself. Sometimes it can end up there. In the end, Carlson gets his way, and the dog is killed. Both Candys dog and Lennie die relatively peaceful deaths and do not suffer while dying. Wellhell! Why is the killing of Candys dog a significant incident in the novel. "Yeah," he said. It was an unusual-looking pistol because it was a German Luger. He says that they will be taken care of and Lennie will be protected, What do George and Lennie talk about when Lennie comes into the house? George wouldn't let other people hurt Lennie. Lennie was attracted to the same type of girl in Weed. Why does Carlson shoot Candy's dog? creating and saving your own notes as you read. He wants to put the dog out of its missery.Candy didnt want him to do that becase hes been with this dog forever. Candy will survive through his friendship of Lennie and George. Candy is introduced in the start of chapter two, he is described indirectly by the narrator as a Stoop shouldered old man(Steinbeck 18). Why does my dog cry when he sees other dogs? Why did George at one time play jokes on Lennie? Curley has accused Slim of eying his wife, a charge which Slim and the others laugh off. When Slim offers Candy a puppy and says of the . Any action you take based on the information found on nahf.org is strictly at your discretion. What are Carlsons reasons for shooting Candys dog How could this incident foreshadow possible events to come? Candy had with his dog and the one George has with Lennie. But the play could only run for about an hour and a half. Carlson eventually takes the dog out of the room and shoots it; Candy does not try to stop him, he just sits there looking up at the ceiling, he doesn't do anything, because slim agrees with Carlson that he should shoot it and Slim agreed to give Candy one of his puppies. John Steinbeck and Of Mice and Men Background. . The main reason why Carlsons killing of Candys dog was justified is because the old dog was well past its years and of no use to anyone. Carlsons view of Candys dog also hints at the humanity of putting the dog out of its misery, something they couldnt do for an old man like Candy. Home Miscellaneous Quick Answer: Why Does Carlson Want To Shoot Candys Dog. Curley was so used to getting what he wants. (one code per order). Ultimately, Candy agrees to Carlson's request, and the dog is shot.There are a number of reasons why Carlson may have chosen to shoot Candy's dog. To whom does Candy look for advice before allowing Carlson to shoot his dog? The way the characters react towards the shooting of Candys dog reveals a lot abut the characters that we might not have expected. Wanting the best for his dog, Candy allows Carlson to kill him. An he aint no good to himself. Hes all stiff with rheumatism. Later, in chapter three, Carlson gives two more reasons why the dog should be put down. Why does Carlson shoot Candys dog? Both the book and the play came out in the same year, 1937. Why is Crookss room set apart from the others? In this quote, Candy talks about what they done to [his] dog because he wasnt no good to himself nor nobody else. He repeats Slims earlier sentiment about wishing somebodyd shoot him when he was no longer able to work and earn money at the ranch. If you don't see it, please check your spam folder. This shows how Candy is isolated due to his disability. After his dog was shot, it was almost described as if it was Candy that got shot. When they arrive at the ranch, Lennie and George meet Candy and his elderly dog as they are introduced to the others in the bunkhouse. If George had not killed Lennie, he knew someone else would in a more painful way. At the end of the novel, George kills Lennie in much the same way as Carlson kills Candys dog. How Did Critics React to Of Mice and Men? I don't care if you're the best welter in the country. When they arrive at the ranch, Lennie and George meet Candy and his elderly dog as they are introduced to the others in the bunkhouse. This shows that he is lonely because when his dog dies he losses his only friend. Quotes from Carlson, a ranch-hand, reveals this saying, "Whyn't you get Candy to shoot his old dog and give him one of the pups to raise up?, I can smell that dog a mile away., Got no teeth, damn near blind, can't eat. Candys loneliness affects George and Lennie and alters the dream to a three man thing instead of just George and Lennie., The Significance of the Killing of Candy's Dog in Of Mice and Men. Continue to start your free trial. She searched for her dog for weeks, but he was never found. Carlson shoots the dog, and a while later, Candy tells George : "I ought to of shot that dog myself, George. A flophouse Not affiliated with Harvard College. 57, 58), To live off of the fat of the land implies that the land will offer people whatever they need to survive. What is the relationship between Candy and his dog? By killing Lennie himself, George isnt left with guilt or regret. Finally, Carlson may have simply felt that it was the right thing to do. But they wont do nothing like that. That dog ain't no good to himself. The structure of the novel most resembles a ________. He wrote a letter to the editor, praising the publication. By the time Lennie finally relaxes his grip, Curley's hand has been ruined. How does Lennie respond? Candy's dog is a loyal companion that has been with him for . Bad things happen when Lennie tries to take care of himself. Life was dangerous for itinerant farm workers during the Great Depression. on 50-99 accounts. However, it is important to note that not everyone in the novel is like Carlson. Candy feeds him milk. Then, Candy doesnt want Carlson to shoot his dog because its his only companion. Candy sympathizes with the old dog's situation and refuses to kill the animal that he loves. Why is the man in the magazine? Renews May 8, 2023 Central Idea Essay: Who Is to Blame for the Death of Curley's Wife? I wisht somebody'd shoot me if I got old an' a cripple.". Carlson knew that Candy loved that dog, and he knew how much she would miss it. $24.99 The guys leaves him back at the ranch while they go to drink and sleep with women. He walked over with his heavy-legged stride and looked down at the dog. You may cancel your subscription on your Subscription and Billing page or contact Customer Support at custserv@bn.com. Carlson believes the dog is too old and decrepit to be of any use. Renew your subscription to regain access to all of our exclusive, ad-free study tools. Accessed 1 May 2023. Who are the experts?Our certified Educators are real professors, teachers, and scholars who use their academic expertise to tackle your toughest questions. In this quote, Candy talks about what they done to [his] dog because he wasnt no good to himself nor nobody else. He repeats Slims earlier sentiment about wishing somebodyd shoot him when he was no longer able to work and earn money at the ranch. Describe the nature of the argument between Curley and Slim. The other men are not scared of Curley. Worse than the dog parallel, though, is that Candy (unlike his dog) is emotionally broken by this whole affair. George and Lennie, who remain behind, begin to discuss their future farm. $18.74/subscription + tax, Save 25% She loved that dog more than anything and couldn't believe that Carlson would do something like that. Use the phrases below to write complete sentences about what you and your friends do every Saturday. What differences do you see? And he sees where Carlson keeps it under his mattress. Related Read: Can my dog smell my other dogs ashes? The smell of Candy's dog irritates him because it reminds him of his miserable existence. What does talking about the dream do for Lennie and George? Ultimately, Candy has littlechoice but to free the dog because Carlson is continuing to aggressively push him and there is potential for further harm. Whynt you get Candy to shoot his old dog and give him one of the pups to raise up? I ain't mad. He wants to be, Candy is lonely because of his old age. In "Of Mice and Men", Carlson shoots Candy's old, disabled dog because he believes that it is the humane thing to do. Second, he states that the dog "stinks like hell." Through these characters, Steinbeck helps the reader understand the stereotype of the uselessness of the elderly and disabled. Although Curley is the boss's son, they refuse to let Curley physically intimidate them. Candy says, I dont mind takin care of him. (45)., Soon after they arrive at the ranch, George and Lennie meet some new and delightful people that they will be living with, until they earn enough money to buy a place of their own. Since George sees the pain and suffering Candy goes through after he expresses that he oughtta shot that dog [himself] shouldnt oughtta of let no stranger shoot [his] dog (), George takes matters into his own hands when the entire ranch is out to kill Lennie. Describe the conversation George and Lennie have after the men go in search of a fight between Cruley and Slim. George describes to Lennie the sights, sounds, and smells of the farm they hope to someday own and the description interests Candy. George knew that Lennie would continue to get into trouble and maybe hurt more people, so did what was best for him. By signing up you agree to our terms and privacy policy. Candy also had a close relationship with his dog. He thinks he will soon be not useful to the ranch because he will be disabled and old, much like his dog. Purchasing Mentally, Lennie survives with the rabbits. Finally, Carlson may have simply felt that it was the right thing to do. I'llI'll smash 'em with a stick" (p. 58). Carlson says the dog aint no good to Candy, unable to see that the dog still has value as Candys friend and companion. However, they also knew how much Candy loved the dog and how hard it was for him to lose it. Save over 50% with a SparkNotes PLUS Annual Plan! That dog of Candys is so God damn old he cant hardly walk. They says he wasn't no good to himself nor nobody else(Steinbeck 60). Had him since he was a pup. In the first chapter of Of Mice and Men, what does George say to Lennie about how his life could be better without him? Fifth, the dog can no longer eat solid food; Candy gives the dog milk. Your group members can use the joining link below to redeem their group membership. The other ranch hands felt conflicted about Carlson shooting Candy's dog. What changes might an older person experience that would affect his or her clothing needs? Reads 1.5K. After George, Lennie, and Candy make a pact not to tell anyone about their dream, Candy makes the following statement: "I oughtta of shot that dog myself, George. Why does Carlson want to shoot Candy's dog? The ending puts a "frame" around the story. When Candy tells George about his injury he says, "I got hurt four years ago. Youve successfully purchased a group discount. When George tells Lennie that they need to build a stake, he is talking about money. Carlson explains to Candy exactly why the old dog should be put out of its misery. Before George meets Lennie in the woods in the final scene, whose gun does he take, The structure of the novel most resembles a ________, Lennie scares the girl in the red dress in the town of Weed, Of Mice and Men was first published in 1937, Curley keeps vaseline in one of his gloves to help soothe a boxing injury, A cat house is an another term for whorehouse or brothel, George is the first person to discover Curly's wife dead body, Candy will still go buy the farm on his own, he will not be deterred by George and Lennie, Whit reads aloud a letter he sent to the editor that he wrote and was published in a Western Magazine, Curly always wears a bull whip to show that he has much more power than any of the other ranch workers, Curley's wife invites Lennie to hold her hands and rub her shoulders, English 1 Exam Study Guide Of Mice and Men, Financial Statement Analysis Exam 1 Comprehen, Financial Markets and Institutions Chapter 7, Financial Markets & Institutions Chapter 6, Financial Markets & Institutions Chapter 5, Block 2 pain pathway and synaptic transmission. I wont have no place to go, an I cant get no more jobs. George probably kept Lennie as a buddy for protection as well as for companionship. This event is a clear indication of Carlson's personality, and it is one of the reasons why he is not a likable character. She was angry at the person who shot him and felt like she needed to take revenge. For the next 7 days, you'll have access to awesome PLUS stuff like AP English test prep, No Fear Shakespeare translations and audio, a note-taking tool, personalized dashboard, & much more! Why? This event likely contributed to Candy's eventual downfall, as he became increasingly bitter and isolated after losing his only companion. A(n) ___ is someone who creates and runs his or her own business. Why do you think George encourages Lennie to fight back when Curley hits him? Why does Lennie have a dead mouse in his pocket? There is no investigation or interrogation. Candy had to agree to let Carlson shoot his old dog because the author mandated it for plot purposes. I don't know nothing that stinks as bad as an old dog. He is mad at the puppy because it died and he throws the puppy at the wall. Purchasing How do the descriptions of Curley change throughout the fight? What are the two main reasons why Carlson Wants Candys dog to be put to sleep? Curley flops like a fish. Carlson says that he will shoot Candy's dog in the back of the neck where the neck and head meet. He offers his life savings to George and Lennie to help finance their dream. creating and saving your own notes as you read. Although George and Lennie try to stop Carlson from shooting the dog, they are not ultimately successful. Why do dogs lay down when they see another dog? Everybody thinks it was Lennie who stole the Luger after he killed Curley's wife and fled from the ranch. Why did Steinbeck choose the title Of Mice and Men? Candy was heartbroken when her dog was shot. If he shots the dog at this place, he tells Candy that the dog wont feel anything. Curley stated that he would shoot him if he found him and slim planned on locking Lennie up in a mental hospital if he found him alive. on 2-49 accounts, Save 30% George tells Lennie to let go, but Lennie only grips harder out of fear. Whit enters the bunkhouse with a magazine featuring a man he used to work with. "Don't you remember Bill Tenner? It's also possible that Carlson was simply acting out of self-defense after the dog charged at him. No doubt Carlson was in World War I and brought it back as a souvenir. Why does Carlson want to shoot Candy's dog? If you was to take him out and shoot him right in the back of the head right there whyd hed never know what hit him.() Carlson made it obvious that he wanted to kill Candys dog but that the dog wouldnt suffer. His dog enters later in chapter two, whom is described as a dragfooted sheepdog, gray of a muzzle, and with pale, old eyes(Steinbeck 26). When Steinbeck was plotting his story he wanted to end it with George killing Lennie. There is noeasy answer to this question; Candy may feel sympathy for the dog and want to avoid any further bruises or harm, or he may hope that by leaving the situation the dog will be less likely to become aggressive. Related Read: Why do dogs lay down when they see another dog? Your subscription will continue automatically once the free trial period is over. on 2-49 accounts, Save 30% Describe the conversation George and Lennie have after the men go in search of a fight between Cruley and Slim. Worked here about three months ago?". (His dog is old and weak; he is disabled. While Carlson is speaking to Slim (in chapter two of John Steinbeck's Of Mice and Men ), he states the many reasons that Candy's dog needs to be put down. Second, Carlson says that the dog is no good for Candy. Lennie's first impulse is to kill the cats, just as Carlson's is to shoot Candy's dog. Do George and Candy still plan to buy the dream farm after Lennies death? Candys dog wasn't in good health and Lennie killed Curly's wife and would be in trouble with the law. Youve successfully purchased a group discount. The dog is mean and tried to bite him. Log in here. Copyright 1999 - 2023 GradeSaver LLC. Carlsons view of Candys dog also hints at the humanity of putting the dog out of its misery, something they couldnt do for an old man like Candy. Why does George kill Lennie in Of Mice and Men? But this friendship didn't last because Carlson continuously complained about the odor produced by the dog. He would only allow himself to do something; Lennie and the dog both need someone else to survive with and both grew up with either George or Candy when they were younger. Why does carlson want to shoot candy's dog? Candy replies that he has had the dog for too many years to kill it, but Carlson continues to pressure him. Explain the following passage and its function in the story: Foreshadowing leading up to what could possibly happen( since there was conflict between curley's wife and the men. We're sorry, SparkNotes Plus isn't available in your country. Carlson is a very callous character, and he does not seem to have any compassion for others. Why does George lie about the gun? What quotes show that Crooks is lonely in Of Mice and Menby John Steinbeck? Carlson's reasoning for wanting to shoot the dog is that the dog is old and suffering. What does Curley's wife offer to let Lennie touch? Carlson shot Candys dog to put it out of its misery because Candy couldnt bring himself to do it. Best summary PDF, themes, and quotes. In the end, Candy is isolated due to his age and disability., An aging ranch handyman, Candy lost his hand in an accident and worries about his future on the ranch. Related Read: Does lazy dog have a dog menu? A ranch workers life during this time period was determined by his usefulness, and survival was directly linked to his ability to physically work.