Does John treat Jamie unfairly because hes adopted, or because of the reasons listed above? But as the fan finally pointed out, even though Jamie isnt a Dutton in blood, he certainly is in action. Many fans of the neo-western series think this suggests Beth was once pregnant with Rips child and Jamie either did something to cause a miscarriage or persuaded her to get an abortion that possibly left her unable to have any more kids. Alita: Battle Angel Producer Gives Hopeful Update On The Sequel, And How Avatar 2 Is Connected, Jason Momoa Clarifies Feelings On Aquaman, Talks Frustration Of The Lost Kingdom Not Using Many Of His Ideas, David Arquette Admits To Feeling Inferior To Courteney Cox While She Was On Friends, And Explained How He Worked Through Those Feelings, Following Sydney Sweeney And Glen Powell Rumors, Photo Of Her Fianc Leaving The House With Bags Sparks More Debate, The Marvelous Mrs. Maisels Michael Zegen Reveals The Unexpected Way He Learned About Joels Fate, Nick Cannon Reacts To The Red Table Talk Cancellation, Related It To Will Smith And Chris Rock's Oscars Slap, Keanu Reeves Proves To Be The Sweetest In Adorable Viral TikTok Of Him Meeting A Young Toy Story 4 Fan, Peacocks Twisted Metal Trailer Shows That Anthony Mackie Having Fun In PlayStation Game Adaptation, And So Is Sweet Tooth, The Ballad Of Songbirds And Snakes Trailer Has The Internet Hilariously Realizing An OG Hunger Games Character Is A Nepo Baby. In a strange reaction to his daughters assertion, John did not deny it. John accused Wade of stealing something from him. Their second son died after Monica was involved in a car accident while going to the hospital to give birth. The Dutton family on the hit Paramount Network series "John Dutton adopted Jamie when Wade went to jail for killing his wife. #YellowstoneTV @modernwest @Yellowstone. The shows Costume Designer Janie Bryant spoke exclusively with SOAPS about what it was like creating the outfits for each location in 1923. Is this why Johns always casting him out of the family? John legally adopted & raised him from infancy. WebNo, I do not feel sorry for him one bit. Beth is the one who convinced Jamie to come home. John Dutton III is obviously the main star of Yellowstone, but his grandparents are still unknown. After learning about Jamie killing the reporter, she told him that he should kill himself -- a remark not far off from their fathers to Jamie in the episode when it happened. Monica is a perceptive person, who more than likely has her doubts about that story. Beth Dutton. The question that brought up is why they are giving Malcolm another day? Real Dutton Ranch Location. The world doesnt value your way of life anymore, Dad. She couldnt wage this war by herself. WHAT HAPPENED TO COOL HEADS? | As the episode began, a Native American mom discovered that her older daughter Sila hadnt made it home the night before. And very painful for her. The end of 1923 season 1 left viewers with more questions than answers. Is it because Jaime is Randall's son? Heres where things get a little more confusing. WebWhy did Jon and Evelyn Dutton adopt Jamie? And at one point, they did some quick math on Garretts prison time. Ya just gotta kill em when ya find em. How, she responded, were they supposed to be found when manpower was so low, Chief Rainwater had had to call Kayce for extra hands. First off, John did not raise his children well after his wife died. Why Do Beth and Jamie Hate Each Other on Yellowstone? We know it wasnt always like this. 2. Who is Joe Rogan Dating: What You Know About His Dating History? After the search for Sila yielded the expected result her body was found in a ditch Monica was understandably upset by the unfairness of it all. Beth thinks what Garrett did is what Jamie ultimately wanted. Garrett clearly knows how to play the long game, and based on his words to Jamie earlier this Yellowstone season, we know hes going to come for the Duttons again someday. Helen is a lifelong fan of the horror genre which started in the 1980s when films like Gremlins and Cats Eye scared the life out of her as a kid. Unfortunately, he had no idea how to provide it for her, what with his rodeo days being over and all. The story goes that Jamie's biological father murdered his mother, and was then sent to prison. Is there any genuine reason for it? Beth became pregnant as a teen with Rips child and turned to Jamie for support. Jamie has faithfully taken the course John Dutton set for him his entire life. Thats what has propelled them into this position of running the ranch, running the family, being the linchpin around whom, at this moment in time, the family revolves., Ford added: Their lives are totally wrapped up in each otherTheres very little that sustains them other than themselves and the hard work and investment they put into their future and their family, he explained. When Kayce, clearly not getting it at all, told his wife not to make it her fault, she had to explain, Im not making it my fault, Im making it my problem. Hear her, Kayce. Spencer Dutton meets and marries Alex Dutton (Julia Schlaepfer) in Africa before venturing home. And they aint even our girls, replied Colby. He transported her to a native American abortion clinic without telling her, where the procedure includes sterilization. Because of his familys background, Jamie has a tendency toward evil, and Beth has decided to make his life as miserable as possible. She bit back that John does not love Jamie like he does her and Kayce. The release date for Season 2 of 1923 hasnt been announced, but we assume that it could be be released at the end of 2023, but most likely sometime 2024. Yellowstone fans found out in season 3 that Jamie was adopted by John and Evelyn Dutton when he was just three months old. By the end of Yellowstones latest episode, John had a message delivered to Malcolm Beck -- the dead bodies of the two men that Beck had sent. And you are evil. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. We already know Garrett had a connection with Terrell Riggins in prison because they were cellmates. WebJohn Dutton has not done the best job of protecting Jamie from Beths wrath. But why is Beth so hostile toward Jamie? Beth Dutton, played by Kelly Reilly, is the daughter of cattle rancher John Dutton on the hit TV series Yellowstone. Based on John and Garrett Randalls interactions in Season 4, we know John adopted Jamie so that hed have a better life than his criminal father. So was it just about the money? Then, of course, there was the not-so-small issue of Jamie Yellowstone's Kelly Reilly Offers Explanation For Her PaleyFest Absence, American Idol's Top 10 Revealed Live, Following Pair of Brutal Eliminations, Morning Show Renewed for Season 4 Plus, Find Out When Season 3 Will Air, Time100: The World's Most Influential People, Felicity Dj Vu on The Diplomat? The 1883 TV show begins the story ofYellowstones Dutton family tree, but not all of the family that were alive in that year are actually seen until 1923. Yellowstone airs on Sundays at 9 pm ET on Paramount Network. John made you into something you had no business being. In the seventh episode of Yellowstone, he did attempt to curb some of it, by telling Beth to lay off Jamie. When she balked as only Beth could, her father pleaded with her to reveal what she knew that the rest of them didnt. Her writing has allowed her to visit NYC for Fashion Week events since 2015, and she's worked with clients in almost every field, from dentistry to law and family to entertainment. Phyllis Mary Randall was Phyllis Mary Dutton, Johns sister. I didnt mean me, his dad replied. It is so rife with betrayal. Some fans speculate that its because Jamies adopted. You have to know that. Jamie feebly protested that hed only ever tried to protect the family. In season three, the bomb got dropped on Jamie that he was never biologically a Dutton at all, but a Randall. 1923 is streaming exclusively on Paramount Plus. and our Teeter, played by Jennifer Landon in the neo-western drama series "Yellowstone," works as a ranch hand on John Dutton's ranch. That seemed to happen during Season 3 when Jamie insisted on getting to know his biological father more. It is any wonder what Season 3 has in store. Or maybe his desire to please people. John then recalls how he gave him a job several years ago and "you [Wade] stole the one thing a cowboy doesn't steal." Or maybe because hed rather harbor hate for the After being sentenced to jail, Garrett hoped that his son would have a better life with a different family who could love him and provide for him. Paramount Networks Yellowstone took TV by storm in 2018 and has been a hit since. Does it have anything to do with Johns once-spoken-of brother? Yellowstone showed John trying to take a step in a positive direction with his son in the present day. Were so excited, she told us exclusively at the 1923 Paley Center exhibit. Here However, the Yellowstone fandom thinks there may be something else at work that explains Beths hatred for Jamie something so terrible it would spur her to tell him to commit suicide and threaten to destroy any future happiness he might have. The Dutton family history is lengthy and gets a bit complex at times across the series. When Does Yellowstone Return For Season 5, Part 2? "A lot of those scenes are really difficult to play because they are so filled with pain. WebJamie (Wes Bentley) and Beth (Kelly Reilly) have never had a simple relationship on Yellowstone, even from the very first season. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. WebYellowstone airs on Paramount Network and the series follows the Dutton family on the Yellowstone Dutton Ranch, and there is an ongoing feud between Beth Dutton (played Kayce Dutton is married to Monica (Kelsey Asbille), and they have a son called Tate (Brecken Merrill). Scan this QR code to download the app now. I know you never steal a cowboy's hat, but I've gotta think this animosity between Wade and John is more than that. Helen Armitage is a freelance writer based in the UK who has been writing online since late 2013. Only reason he started to try and bring Kayce back into his life is because Kayce is the only one with a living heir to pass on the ranch and to me, he wanted Tate on that ranch early so he can start brainwashing and indoctrinating him in the way the Yellowstone is run. From his point of view, he was there for Beth when she needed him and tried to keep everyone safe. Thankfully, before John could break any promises not to beat the life out of Jamie, Kayce came in and broke up the scene. They have worked so hard to get back together, and they have earned this second chance at their family. Swap the cows for oil and anyone could be forgiven for thinking the show was a modern-day Dallas or Dynasty rip-off. But after she died, John came down really hard on Jamie, especially after he went to Harvard for law school. It can be difficult to follow, but the Yellowstone Ranchs Dutton family tree is explained one show at a time. Jamie betrayed Beth by keeping her in the dark about the abortions effects, which Beth will never be able to forgive. Meanwhile Market Equities CEO Willa Hayes arrived in town for a sit-down with Roarke and Jamie. Cinemablend is part of Future US Inc, an international media group and leading digital publisher. Even if a viewer has watched all three Yellowstone series shows, the Dutton family tree is confusing because some characters were alive and part of the family tree in 1883 but not actually shown or discussed until 1923. Doing this sort of work is a journey into the unknown, she added. See whos among the Dutton family in our gallery below. The two finally confronted one another at a local diner and the tension definitely thickened in the room. One person replied to the post with three reasons why they think John and Jamie didnt get along. Claires husband, Henry, died before 1883, but he is survived by his wife and daughter, Mary Abel (Emma Malouff), who dies while traveling to Montana with her family. Amazingly, Jamie believes he did nothing wrong, which explains why he has no idea why his sister is angry. The 28-year-old actress said that she cant wait to start working on Season 2 and spoke about the cast and crews tight-knit relationship. 1923 is the the second Yellowstone spin-off series streaming exclusively on Paramount Plus. When they first met, he questioned Randall about his prior deeds, and Randall was willing to accept and defend his wrongdoing. In chronological order, the Dutton family tree began in 1883. Knowing how Kayce and the Duttons handle things, will she accept what they are going to do about it? Hed ensured that his sister could never have children, she reminded him. For the most part, their interactions have been awful, with Beth raking Jamie over and over again with incendiary barbs. So I always start with my design boards and getting a scope of visual reference to create these characters.. Wade then replies, "Come and get it. Which is exactly what John plans to do. Doesnt mean we shouldnt try, Monica replied. Were all so close in the cast and crew, so getting to work with these people again is such a dream and I feel so lucky.. The first significant disagreement between Jamie and the Duttons arose when he selfishly refused to withdraw his attorney general campaign. Has he been keeping tabs on John and Jamie this whole time, saving up his pennies to finance the big hit? the user wrote in their post. 1923 season 2 is happening, so the story of John Dutton IIIs grandparents will likely play out. Garrett confirms he spent 30 years in a concrete box before he got out. but Jamie sees John treat Beth as an important asset, not John exploiting her At the end of their intense conversation, John tells Wade, "You have something that belongs to me." The Dutton family tree will fill in the final missing pieces as 1923 season 2 airs. Jamie knows that his father and henchmen Rip and Lloyd have been murdering men for decades. Yelowstone fans debate their origin of Jamie and John Duttons strained realtionship. So maybe those ten years out of prison were spent watching and waiting patiently. Kevin Costner has provided some insight into Johns relationships with his children. In the midseason episode of Season 3, those superfans were left perplexed when a newer character came to town and John Dutton, played by Kevin Costner, finds himself face to face with yet another enemy from his past, Wade Morrow, played by Boots Southerland. You need someone who is capable of making decisions, and hopefully making the right decisions, but at least making a decision and going with itin other words, a leader, Mirren said. Britt Lawrence from CinemaBlend has multiple theories when it comes to the stolen goods in question. Kinda like Rip in a sense, but way more disappointing At one of Jamies lowest moments, he confides in his father about feeling betrayed by the people he believed were his family up to this point. Subscribe to our newsletter for new stories, tips & events. Why does Jamies own father not love him? Kelly Riley, the actress who plays Beth on Yellowstone, talked about why Beth hates Jamie so much in an interview with Entertainment Tonight. By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. You see that look? Yellowstone Season 4 Episode 9 delivered a lot of key moments that will all build up to the season finale airing next week. But I guess she thought she could save him. Two dances [with Laramie], and here I am hauling them to the arena, saddling their horses, he marveled to Jimmy. At the Duttons place, Jamie sorta randomly decided that he was sick of being picked on by Beth, so he wanted to address the elephant in the room, right then, right there. Damn it, Lloyd, what are you getting that boy into besides traction? The actress Kelly Reilly, who plays Beth in the film Yellowstone, brought up an intriguing point during a recent interview with Entertainment Tonight: There are times when I feel terrible for Jamie. Yellowstone fans found out in season 3 that Jamie was adopted by John and Evelyn Dutton when he was just three months old. Yellowstone: TV series starring Kevin Costner from director/writer Taylor Sheridan. So, why wouldnt he take revenge sooner? As announced in a new report from EW, Yellowstone season 4 will debut on Paramount+ on November 7th, 2021, featuring the return of the Dutton family led by Costner. But I believe she loved him, which is why everything is there. Killing John for Garretts personal vendetta would only hurt Jamie when he was happy to be a Dutton. The brother and sister have shared a few close moments. On the well-liked Yellowstone television series on the Paramount Network, Jamie and Beth grew up as siblings (2018- ). The fan specifically referenced Season 4 Episode 5, where apparently one of them talks about the fact that Jamies not really a Dutton., The original poster wants to know if thats because he was adopted? Garrett saw it as the opportunity he needed to eliminate John from the picture and secure his sons future as the owner of the Yellowstone Dutton Ranch. WebJohn don't love Kayce either. Most branded men are never allowed to leave the ranch alive. Kayce and his family only got to enjoy that happiness for a short while before the unthinkable happened. While airing on a smaller network, the show still boasts an impressive 94 / 100 rating on Google and has amassed a cult following of fans. 'Yellowstone' Just Revealed a Major Plot Twist About Jamie Dutton's Parentage. WebFor the entire run of the series, all John has done is abuse and manipulate Jamie. In the seventh episode of Yellowstone , he did attempt to curb some of it, by telling Beth to lay Truer words might never have been spoken. For more information, please see our Lee dies in the first episode of Yellowstone season 1. WebJohn Dutton Sr. (James Badge Dale) is the namesake of Yellowstone's John Dutton and is the second child of James and Margaret. Ya cant stop the world from being bad, he said, totally ignoring my sound advice. Will Jamie screw over Daddy? Jamie is involved with a woman named Christina, and they welcome a child that no one is familiar with yet. The Views Sunny Hostin Shares Her Thoughts On Don Lemons Firing: It Doesn't Make Sense, Ben Stiller Addressed Alleged Drama On Severance Set Following Rumors About The Apple TV+ Series Being Delayed. ---- The Dutton clan on neo-western drama Yellowstone is hardly the most functional family unit, but why does Beth hate her brother Jamie so much? When does 1923 return for Season 2? In Yellowstone, John Dutton IIIs late wife is Evelyn Dutton (Gretchen Mol). All Rights Reserved. In an interview with Vanity Fair in November 2022, Ford and Mirren spoke about their characters strong relationship, which is tested and depended on in the many tumultuous battles they face, from getting shot at to protecting their land from greedy men. The third season essentially saw the Is There a Real Story Behind the Luckiest Girl Alive? Since his adoption as a child, the family has just tolerated him. Fans have some theories! John III and Evelyn are the parents of Kayce (Luke Grimes), Lee (Dave Annable), and Beth Dutton (Kelly Reilly). All of that takes away any official motive for John or his family to kill the Becks. What am I missing? Elsewhere, Mia and Laramie heard about the nearby buffalo, and off they went with the bunk-house boys to see if they could take a ride. How would you rate this article? WebFans have been theorizing why Beth hates Jamie since last season when the two got into a physical fight at their father's ranch. She is one of the most complex and interesting characters on the show. That is what her job is. Everything Ive done, muttered John in disbelief, its all for nothing. What had left the Dutton familys patriarch feeling so downtrodden? Is it a prized belt buckle that Johns late father gave him? But something about that line struck one Yellowstone fan on Reddit recently. It is a tough life, and its full of not just physical challenges but moral ones as well., When does 1923 return for Season 2? Then shed have to teach Kayce how to fight, John said. Beth became pregnant as a teen with Rips child and turned to Jamie for support. Until this Yellowstone scene, we had no idea that Garrett even had a bone to pick with John. Initially it appeared to be from their Jacob and Cara did not have children of their own in 1923, but they did take over the Yellowstone Ranch in the early 1900s after James and Margaret died. When Kayce went to see Jaime to ask him to look into who attacked the family, Jaime said John hates me. During the course of the seventh episode of Season 3, John and Wade discuss many past events and ambiguous references that left fans guessing, including one particular moment when John recalls how he gave him a job several years ago and "you [Wade] stole the one thing a cowboy doesn't steal." Nor did they confirm if viewers would find out in Season 2. But the ex-con revealed that John couldve told the judge the truth about Jamies mother becoming a drug addict. They adopted Jamie Dutton (Wes Bentley), whose birth father is Garrett Randall (Will Patton). They are the parents of Jack Dutton (Darren Mann). John rebutted by saying Garrett turned her into an addict and killed her for it. The following morning, Beth warned John that what Yellowstone was facingit isnt an enemy, its a perspective, its a shift in values. What are the Filming Locations for Yellowstone Season 5? Why do John and Beth (especially)treat him like garbage? 4. He transported her to a native American abortion clinic without telling her, where the procedure includes sterilization. All the Queen Men Season 3 Release Date: is There Any Trailer for. Some followers believe that Johns mother played a significant role in his life or was Evelyns sister. Riding bucking broncos had been supposed to be his ticket to Easy Street. WebIf Jamie has blamed Beth for their mothers accidental death all their lives, thats reason enough for her to hate him. Beth, again, had keen insight, The more you become what he wants, the more he will hate you for it. Before reuniting with Jamie, he had been living on a rural ranch after serving his prison term for the murder of his wife.